Understanding the difference between criminal law and civil law is essential for anyone living or doing business in New South Wales. Whether you’re dealing with a dispute, facing charges, or simply want to understand your rights under the NSW legal framework, knowing which area of law applies can save you stress, time, and money.
At Lyon Legal Services, we often meet clients who are unsure whether their issue is civil or criminal—and that confusion is incredibly common. Both legal areas involve courts, evidence, lawyers, and disputes, but the purpose and processes behind each are very different.
In this detailed guide, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know:
What criminal law is and how it works in NSW
What civil law covers, including common disputes
The burden of proof in each system
How NSW courts handle criminal vs civil matters
Real-world examples around local landmarks
Situations where a case can be both criminal and civil
How to get the right legal help
Let’s start by breaking them down clearly.
Speak with our NSW legal team now
1. What Is Criminal Law in NSW?
Criminal law deals with conduct considered harmful to the community, public safety, or the state. When someone breaks a criminal law in NSW—whether that’s assault, theft, drink driving, drug offences, or fraud—they are seen as committing a wrongdoing against society, not just an individual person.
1.1 The Purpose of Criminal Law
The purpose of criminal law is to:
Protect the public
Deter harmful behaviour
Maintain order and safety
Punish and rehabilitate offenders
In NSW, criminal offences are prosecuted to uphold community standards, whether the event occurs near Circular Quay, Sydney CBD, Newcastle Foreshore, or any suburb across the state.
1.2 Who Brings a Criminal Case?
Criminal cases are brought by the State of New South Wales, typically through:
NSW Police
The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP)
Victims don’t prosecute the case themselves, although they may provide evidence or victim impact statements.
For example, if a serious assault occurs near Darling Harbour, the police investigate, and the DPP may prosecute—regardless of whether the victim wants to “drop charges.”
1.3 Court Pathways for Criminal Matters
Criminal matters usually begin in the Local Court, including regional courts like:
Downing Centre Local Court (Sydney)
Parramatta Local Court
Wollongong Local Court
More serious offences move to:
NSW District Court
Supreme Court of NSW (near Queen’s Square)
1.4 Burden and Standard of Proof in Criminal Law
The prosecution must prove the accused is guilty beyond reasonable doubt.
This is the highest legal standard in Australia because a person’s liberty is at stake.
1.5 Penalties and Sentencing in NSW
Penalties depend on the offence and may include:
Imprisonment
Community Correction Orders
Intensive Correction Orders
Good Behaviour Bonds
Fines
Licence disqualification
Criminal conviction recorded
Sentences vary whether the matter is handled at the Downing Centre, Parramatta Justice Precinct, or a regional court.
Speak with our NSW legal team now
2. What Is Civil Law in NSW?
Civil law deals with disputes between individuals, businesses, or organisations. Unlike criminal law—where the goal is to punish wrongdoing—civil law focuses on resolving conflicts and compensating victims.
These disputes can involve:
Contract disagreements
Negligence claims
Property disputes
Defamation
Personal injury claims
Debt recovery
Workplace disputes
Family law matters (though this is its own branch)
2.1 The Purpose of Civil Law
Civil law aims to:
Protect individual rights
Enforce agreements
Resolve disputes
Compensate people for financial or personal losses
For instance, if someone damages your property near Bondi Beach, that’s not a criminal matter—it’s a civil claim you may take to court or mediation.
2.2 Who Brings a Civil Case?
Unlike criminal cases, civil cases are brought by a private party, known as the plaintiff. They sue another person or business (the defendant) for compensation or another remedy.
2.3 Civil Law Courts in NSW
Civil cases are typically heard in:
NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT)
Local Court (Civil Division)
District Court (Civil Division)
Supreme Court of NSW
Simple disputes—like a repair bill disagreement—may go to NCAT at John Maddison Tower in Sydney.
Larger claims involving hundreds of thousands of dollars often go to the District Court, while major commercial litigation may escalate to the Supreme Court.
2.4 Burden and Standard of Proof in Civil Law
Civil cases use a lower standard of proof:
balance of probabilities.
This means the plaintiff must prove their version of events is more likely than not to be true.
2.5 Remedies in Civil Cases
Instead of punishment, civil law provides remedies such as:
Financial compensation (damages)
Injunctions
Court orders
Specific performance (forcing a party to fulfil a contract)
Declarations
If a contractor fails to complete work on a building in Parramatta, you might sue them for damages or seek an order requiring them to finish the job.
Speak with our NSW legal team now
3. Key Differences Between Criminal and Civil Law (Explained Simply)
Below is a breakdown of the major differences.
3.1 Purpose
| Criminal Law | Civil Law |
|---|---|
| Protect society | Resolve disputes between private parties |
| Punish offenders | Compensate for loss |
| Maintain public order | Enforce rights and agreements |
3.2 Who Starts the Case?
Criminal Law: NSW Police or DPP
Civil Law: A private individual, business, or organisation
3.3 Terminology
Criminal cases involve: accused, charges, prosecution, guilty/not guilty
Civil cases involve: plaintiff, defendant, claim, liability
3.4 Outcome
Criminal: fines, prison, community orders
Civil: compensation, injunctions, orders
3.5 Burden of Proof
Criminal: beyond reasonable doubt
Civil: balance of probabilities
3.6 Court Processes
Both areas use courts around NSW, but the processes differ significantly.
Speak with our NSW legal team now
4. Real-World Examples (NSW Context)
Example 1: Assault at Circular Quay
Criminal: The offender may face assault charges.
Civil: The victim may sue for medical costs or emotional distress.
Example 2: Car Crash in Parramatta
Criminal: Dangerous driving charges may apply.
Civil: A negligence claim for the damage and injuries.
Example 3: Unpaid Invoice in Newcastle
Civil: A business sues for debt recovery at NCAT or Local Court.
No criminal offence unless fraud is involved.
Example 4: Shoplifting in Westfield Penrith
Criminal: Theft charges.
Civil: The store could seek civil recovery costs.
Example 5: Property Damage in Bondi
Criminal: Malicious damage charges.
Civil: Claim for repair costs.
Speak with our NSW legal team now
5. Can a Case Be Both Criminal and Civil? Yes—Here’s How.
Some incidents in NSW give rise to both types of legal action.
Example: Assault
Someone punched outside a venue near Sydney Harbour Bridge may face:
Criminal case: Prosecution for assault
Civil case: Victim sues for medical bills or lost income
These cases run separately with different standards of proof.
Other common dual-path cases include:
Fraud + civil compensation
Property damage + repair claim
Sexual assault + civil damages claim
6. Which One Applies to Your Situation?
Ask yourself:
“Did it harm the public or break a law?” → Criminal
“Is it a private dispute over money, contracts, or rights?” → Civil
If you’re unsure, a lawyer can quickly identify the correct category.
Speak with our NSW legal team now
7. Understanding NSW Court Locations and Landmarks
Knowing where cases are heard can reduce confusion during stressful times.
Key NSW legal locations include:
Sydney Region
Downing Centre Local & District Court – near Hyde Park
NSW Supreme Court – Queen’s Square
NCAT (John Maddison Tower) – Castlereagh Street
Sydney Police Centre – Surry Hills
Western Sydney
Parramatta Justice Precinct
Blacktown Local Court
Penrith Local Court
Regional NSW
Newcastle Courthouse, Hunter Street
Wollongong Courthouse
Lismore Court House
Referencing local landmarks helps clients feel grounded and informed.
8. Why Understanding the Difference Matters for NSW Residents
Knowing whether an issue is criminal or civil affects:
Your rights
Your responsibilities
The timeline
The costs involved
Whether police are involved
Whether you can seek compensation
Which court you’ll attend
For example, many people believe the police will help with unpaid debts—but that’s a civil matter you must pursue privately.
Similarly, some people believe private agreements can lead to criminal charges—when they usually can’t.
9. How Lyon Legal Services Can Help
At Lyon Legal Services, we assist clients across NSW with both criminal and civil matters. Our team has deep knowledge of local courts, procedures, and NSW legislation, whether your case is heard in:
Downing Centre
Parramatta District Court
NCAT Sydney
Newcastle Court
or regional NSW courts
We can help with:
Criminal Law Matters
Assault charges
Drug offences
Domestic violence matters
Theft, fraud, or property offences
Driving and traffic offences
Bail applications
Sentencing advice and representation
Civil Law Matters
Contract disputes
Property and tenancy disputes
Negligence and compensation claims
Debt recovery
Business disagreements
NCAT applications and hearings
Whether you’re walking through the legal precinct near Hyde Park, or attending a tribunal hearing at John Maddison Tower, we guide you through the process with clarity and confidence.
10. Final Thoughts
Understanding the difference between criminal law and civil law in NSW empowers you to protect your rights, make informed decisions, and seek the right legal support.
Criminal law focuses on public safety and punishment.
Civil law focuses on private disputes and compensation.
Both systems have their own courts, evidence standards, and procedures. And in many cases, the same incident can give rise to both types of legal action.
If you’re facing a legal issue and aren’t sure where you stand, Lyon Legal Services is here to help. Our team can assess your situation, explain the path forward, and represent you with professionalism and care.
